The Case Against The Case Against Women In Combat Pt. II

MAJ Edward H. Carpenter, Executive Officer of Marine Aviation Logistics Squadron 40 in Afghanistan, authored an article over at Duck Of Minerva yesterday.  In it Carpenter breaks down what it takes to become a Marine Infantry Officer and explains why opening up the opportunity to female Marines is a good thing.  Of particular interest is his description of the Combat Endurance Test:

[T]he officers are awake before 4 am, get dropped off in the middle of nowhere carrying rifle, a day pack, and a limited supply of food and water. Over the next 12 hours, the officers will be in near continuous motion, while being stressed out physically and mentally. They will swim, run, tread water, navigate with map and compass, perform pull-ups, push-ups, navigate an obstacle course, attempt to reassemble broken-down enemy weapons, and more. They will cover nearly twice as much ground as the enlisted infantryman does on his capstone exercise, the 20K endurance hike.

Read the whole article here.


North Korea Releases Propaganda Video Showing Nuclear Attack On A US City

North Korea’s propaganda department released a video over the weekend showing an apparent nuclear strike against a city in the United States.  The video, presented as a young man’s dream sequence, depicts the launch of a North Korean spaceship via a rocket similar to ones recently tested by the Hermit Kingdom.  While orbiting the Earth in this craft the young man is able to zoom in on different countries (including what appears to be a unified Korea).  Towards the end of the video the camera zooms in on a city covered by an American flag which is subsequently destroyed by a vast explosion.  LiveLeak has a good breakdown of the video here.

Setting aside for a moment the fact the North Korean rocket tests fail more often than they succeed, and that the country’s nuclear capabilities are crude at best, what are we to make of this video?  Is it cry for attention from a mausolocracy that is currently run by an attention starved little boy?  Is it rash posturing in the wake of UN condemnation of North Korean nuclear ambitions?  Or is it meant as a genuine threat to the enemies of Kim Jong Un?  One thing that does seem clear is that, while Iran sticks to the story of nuclear development for civilian energy needs, North Korea has no bones about making public her nuclear intentions.

The Case Against The Case Against Women In Combat

On the 24th of January the Department of Defense announced that it would do away with the 1994 Direct Ground Combat Definition and Assignment Rule for women and open up more combat and combat support Military Occupational Specialties (MOS) to female service members.  This announcement has been hailed as a coup for equal rights activists, but it is an even bigger victory for women who have been facing combat in the asymmetrical battlefields of Iraq and Afghanistan despite this archaic rule and for those seeking advancement in a military hierarchy that reserves its highest echelons for troops who have served honorably in combat related positions from which women were explicitly excluded.  Furthermore, the removal of the barriers put in place by this rule will widen the pool of candidates from which unit level commanders can draw to fill combat positions, thus relieving some of the stress that has been felt by the thinly stretched corps of young officers and non-commissioned officers over the last decade as they have been pressed into multiple tours of duty in Iraq and Afghanistan.

Of course this development has not been met with enthusiasm from all corners of the military.  One of the most outspoken opponents of lifting these barriers is LTG (Ret.) Jerry Boykin.  General Boykin is a US Army veteran, former member of the Special Operations and intelligence communities, and current Executive Vice President of the Family Research Council.  As a fellow veteran, I respect General Boykin and appreciate all that he has done in the service of his country.  But this soldier cum evangelical preacher is stuck in the backwards logic of an era when women were best confined to overseeing matters of the home.  His views on the matter are not only a disservice to the women who have been bravely facing combat for years now, but also to the US military’s ability to prepare all of its members for the rigors of defending the nation.

For a recap and assessment of General Boykin’s thoughts on the matter I recommend the piece written by William Saletan over at Slate.  It suffices to say that General Boykin thinks very little of a woman’s ability to go without certain amenities of personal hygiene for extended periods, or of a man’s ability to serve side-by-side with a women without being embarrassed about having to do so.  This is to say nothing of the General’s lack of confidence in the military’s ability to uphold the standards of combat readiness or his seeming lack of understanding that women have already been serving on the front lines for over a decade in Iraq and Afghanistan where the front line is everywhere.

I posted my full thoughts on the DOD’s decision earlier in the week, and I won’t rehash it here.  I will simply close be reiterating the fact that equal treatment and opportunity are rights that supposedly important in American society.  Upholding them in this case does not require a lowering of standards, a lessening of combat readiness, or institutional detriment in the name of social experimentation.  It will however require a change in the culture of military leadership that sees clearly delineated roles between the sexes instead of taking into account the strengths and weaknesses of the individual soldier and their ability to accomplish the mission.  Not every female trooper will meet the standards required of an Infantry officer or a Fire Support Specialist, but those that can will be an asset to the nation and its military.

A Monumental Tragedy

So I am finally back after a short hiatus in which I spent the holiday season and a couple of weeks thereafter eating, drinking and hibernating in a futile attempt to stave off the inevitable: returning to work.  Anyway, I have returned to the office and to the blog, and I have decided to break my blogging fast with a piece of news that diverges somewhat from the usual topics discussed here, but which has hit very close to home for me.

When I am not working, studying or blogging I find time to serve as Commander of Veterans of Foreign Wars (VFW) Post 10658 in Schweinfurt.  About six years ago this organization, an amazing collective of American combat veterans spanning a wide range of ages and conflicts, was forced to begin to come to grips with the fact that the US Army units and installations that have been here in Schweinfurt since the end of World War II would be closing in the foreseeable future.  It was then that the idea to erect a monument to the service and sacrifice of every Soldier who had been stationed or served in the city from 1946 onward began to take shape.  Four years later we learned that the base closure was coming sooner rather than later and the project to create the monument began in earnest.

Two local artists, Steff Bauer and Sören Ernst, were commissioned to design and create the monument.  The Schweinfurt VFW and its Ladies Auxiliary conducted a huge fundraising effort, raising the vast majority of the funds through private donations from individual donors, the city of Schweinfurt donated a plot of land, and a local construction firm donated time and resources to the monument’s installation.

Finally, on Veterans Day 2012, the American Soldiers Monument was dedicated in a small but proud ceremony.  In attendance was Sissy Borel, National Senior Vice-President of the VFW Ladies Auxiliary; Sebastian Remelé, Lord Mayor of Schweinfurt; LTC Michael Runey, Commander of US Army Garrison Schweinfurt; as well as a host of Veterans, past and present unit and garrison commanders, city officials, members of the media and, perhaps most importantly, the widows of several fallen American heroes.  It was as solemn occasion and every speech delivered that afternoon resonated with the themes of service, sacrifice, and the partnership and friendship of two great nations.

Sadly, just two months later, the pride that was felt on that day has been damaged.  Sometime between the evening of January 15th and the afternoon of January 16th vandals removed the head of the eagle, the national symbol of America and Germany, and made off with it.  The local police were notified; the investigation is ongoing.

I found it difficult to put into words how I felt after I found out about the vandalism.  Shock.  Anger.  Sadness.  I couldn’t sit still; I couldn’t focus on just one emotion.  Questions kept bouncing around in my skull.  Who would do this?  Why would someone do this?  What has it accomplished?  I spent most of the night somewhere between agitation and depression.

I awoke this morning to find that news of the event had begun to make its way around the regional media websites.  The local paper ran a story on the afternoon of the 16th.  The state police reported the attack on their website and provided a hotline for witnesses or individuals with information about the attack to report it; the state news agency reported on it as well.  Several smaller websites that feature local news and events also ran the report from the police website, including one which ran it under the headline, “Who would do something like this?”

This media brush fire, combined with the outpouring of shock, outrage and grief that we have received via email and commentary, has helped tremendously.  It has been heartening to read the messages of support from Veterans, Soldiers, family members, and everyone back in the United States who supported the project.  Additionally, the words that I have received and seen online from German friends and family and the citizens of Schweinfurt have been a welcome boost to morale.  It has been made clear that the desecration of a monument, a piece of art, a piece of this city, will not be tolerated.

This is not the end of the story.  Even now we are working on plans to repair the monument, likely a long and expensive process, and we will see it restored and back where it belongs.  While the symbol may have been defiled, the service, sacrifice, and friendship which it represents continues unabated.  The partnership and sense of community that has been forged over more than 60 years of peacetime cooperation cannot be destroyed so easily.

NRA Says Arming 6-Year-Olds Would Have Prevented Massacre

In lieu of any original content (I just got through with finals week, give me a break) and in light of the recent events in Connecticut, and our subsequent and grave need for a bit of levity, I present a bit of satire from “Mightier Than The Pen.” Following this blog is highly recommended.

Mightier Than The Pen

NRAFairfax, Virginia (AP) – In response to the fatal shooting of 26 people at an elementary school in Newtown, Connecticut, National Rifle Association Executive Vice President Wayne LaPierre said that had the students been allowed to carry a weapon, the murders could have been averted.

“A gun is an easy piece of equipment to use,” said LaPierre at a news conference at NRA headquarters. “A child as young as five can be properly trained to load and aim one. I’m not saying that arming the children would have necessarily prevented all the tragic deaths, but I know the gunman would have thought twice before entering a classroom of two dozen first-graders with upwards of 140 rounds of ammunition at their disposal.”

“And that’s just if you assume each one has a six-shooter,” he continued, referring to the standard revolver. The number of potential deterrent bullets could rise as high as…

View original post 432 more words

Tacos and Dinosaurs

Pop Culture, Humor, and Random Awesomeness by Eric Malcolm

Dawg Pound Nation

Zero BS Cleveland Browns Blog.

USAG Bamberg


The German Way & More

A Voice Made Of Snark And Slander

Oh God, My Wife Is German.

The Misadventures of an American Expat and His Wife in Germany


Rotation Curation for Germany

Break the Broken

Guilty pleasures broken down...

Socialist Currents

Socialist Currents is a publication of Social Democrats USA

Toward a Radical Center

For a Politics of neither the Left nor the Right

Mightier Than The Pen

Making The World A Bitter Place

Socialist Currents

A Voice Made Of Snark And Slander

Closure 2014 Blog

Answering all your Closure 2014 questions

Diary of a Fat Girl

A Voice Made Of Snark And Slander

Just another WordPress weblog

Alex von Halem

A Voice Made Of Snark And Slander


A Voice Made Of Snark And Slander

%d bloggers like this: